Editorial analysis · US manufacturer labels and directions checked November 17, 2026
A packet containing twice as much sodium can produce a drink with the same sodium concentration. You only have to put it in twice as much water.
That sounds obvious until you look at an electrolyte comparison organized entirely around milligrams per packet. The packet is a convenient thing to sell. It is an incomplete description of what ends up in the bottle, and an even less complete description of what someone drinks.
A useful electrolyte comparison needs the amount in the serving, the amount of water and the amount actually consumed. Leave one out and the numbers can answer a different question from the one the reader thinks they are asking.
We checked three specific US products and calculated their sodium concentrations at documented mixing volumes. The result is a reusable reference, not a hydration trial or a ranking of which product is healthiest. We have not tested taste, absorption, exercise performance or whether anyone needs an electrolyte supplement.
Compare the source labels · See what water changes · Download the worksheet
First keep the labels intact
| Product | Serving | Sodium | Potassium | Magnesium | Total sugars | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| LMNT Citrus Salt drink mix | 1 stick (6g) | 1,000mg | 200mg | 60mg | 0g | 5 |
| Liquid I.V. Hydration Multiplier Lemon Lime | 1 stick (16g) | 500mg | 370mg | Not declared on the checked panel | 11g | 50 |
| Nuun Sport Strawberry Lemonade | 1 tablet (5g) | 300mg | 150mg | 25mg | 1g | 15 |
These are three formulations, not three entire brands. LMNT's sparkling can is a different format. Liquid I.V. sells sugar-free and other lines. Nuun sells products beyond Sport tablets. Moving a number from one version to another would undermine the comparison before we touched a calculator.
There is another distinction worth preserving: “not declared” is not the same as zero. The Liquid I.V. panel we inspected does not declare magnesium. We have left that field blank in the CSV and null in the JSON. Filling it with zero would claim knowledge the source did not give us.
The water changes the comparison
Liquid I.V.'s product instructions specify one stick with 16oz of water. Nuun's specify one tablet with 16 fl oz. For LMNT, the brand's endurance-hydration article describes one gram of sodium in 16 to 32 ounces of water and connects that amount to its stick packs. We show both ends of that range. This records the manufacturer's guidance; it does not endorse the page's broader health claims or prescribe a drink concentration.
We treat these US fluid-ounce quantities as water volume and use 29.57353mL per US fl oz, following the NIST conversion. Sixteen US fl oz is about 473mL, not exactly 500mL. We have not measured the finished solution's volume after powder dissolves, so the concentrations below are nominal values per liter of mixing water.
| Product and water | Water volume | Sodium in the whole mix | Nominal sodium concentration |
|---|---|---|---|
| LMNT Citrus Salt, 16 US fl oz | 473mL | 1,000mg | 2,113mg/L |
| LMNT Citrus Salt, 32 US fl oz | 946mL | 1,000mg | 1,057mg/L |
| Liquid I.V. Lemon Lime, 16 US fl oz | 473mL | 500mg | 1,057mg/L |
| Nuun Sport Strawberry Lemonade, 16 US fl oz | 473mL | 300mg | 634mg/L |
The second and third rows are the useful surprise. LMNT in 32 fl oz and Liquid I.V. in 16 fl oz have the same calculated sodium concentration, about 1,057mg/L. But finishing the entire LMNT mix still means consuming 1,000mg sodium; finishing the entire Liquid I.V. mix means 500mg.
Neither statement cancels the other. One answers how concentrated the drink is. The other answers how much sodium is in the complete preparation. A “twice the sodium” headline can be correct per packet and misleading when someone reads it as a comparison of equal volumes.
Equal sodium concentration also does not make the drinks equivalent. Their potassium, sugar, calories and other ingredients differ. We have not calculated osmolality, tested hydration effectiveness or identified the better product for a particular activity. One matched column cannot support those conclusions.
Adding water does not remove what was in the packet
Consider an explicitly hypothetical bottle made with one 500mg-sodium serving. Add 500mL water and the nominal concentration is 1,000mg/L. Add 1,000mL instead and it becomes 500mg/L. The complete bottle still contains 500mg sodium in both examples, assuming nothing was lost.
If someone drinks half of a uniformly mixed bottle, they consume half its contents. In this example that is 250mg sodium, regardless of which bottle size they chose. The water consumed differs. The illustration assumes complete dissolution, even mixing and no spills; it is not an observed drinking session.
This matters when a tracker offers only “one electrolyte drink.” That description might mean one tablet, one packet, one prepared bottle or one glass poured from a larger bottle. The same words can refer to different amounts. Record the product serving and the fraction consumed, then record water volume separately.
A packet cannot tell you an hourly intake
Suppose a hypothetical uniformly mixed drink contains 500mg sodium in 1,000mL. Drinking 600mL of it over two hours corresponds to 300mg total sodium, or an average 150mg per hour. Calling it “500mg per hour” because the packet says 500mg would be a bookkeeping error.
That example is arithmetic, not a suggested intake. We have not measured sweat loss, dietary intake, medical needs or exercise conditions. A concentration table cannot determine those requirements. Anyone managing a prescribed sodium or fluid restriction needs advice matched to that situation, not a product leaderboard.
There is a related shopping error: using a combined “electrolytes” number as though it were sodium. Sodium, potassium and magnesium are separate fields. Adding their masses into one impressive total erases the distinction the buyer needs to inspect. Our reference keeps them separate and does not award a point for having the largest number.
A comparison you can reproduce
Download the four-preparation CSV, source records and methods JSON, and blank bottle worksheet. The JSON also includes the two hypothetical consumption examples, labeled separately from manufacturer observations.
The core calculation is sodium mg/L = sodium mg per serving × servings used ÷ water liters. Estimated sodium consumed is the sodium in the complete mixture multiplied by the fraction of that mixture consumed. Retain the original units until the conversion is explicit, and do not substitute weight ounces for fluid ounces.
We selected these three products because their US manufacturer labels and relevant mixing directions could be inspected. This is not a representative survey, an affiliate ranking or a claim that the highest concentration offers the best value. No purchase, laboratory analysis or performance test was conducted. Labels and directions can change; compare the dated record with your own package.
The protein-price basket applies the same discipline to a different buying decision: keep the original package beside the normalized number. A common denominator should make a comparison more honest, not turn every choice into one score.
Vora permits reuse of our original calculations with attribution and these limits. Brand artwork is excluded. Send corrections to support@askvora.com.
Publisher disclosure: we make Vora. Vora brings proactive AI together with nutrition, workouts and connected wearable context. That context does not turn a drink log into a measurement of electrolyte needs. For a practical introduction to conversational food logging, see our text logging guide.