Two-label investigation · US Nature Made products · Checked November 21, 2026
“1200 mg” is a poor way to compare fish-oil supplements. We found two products from the same manufacturer that put that amount in their names, yet provide very different quantities of EPA and DHA per softgel. The useful comparison begins several rows down the panel.
This is not an accusation of an incorrect label. The information is there. It is an argument against shopping or logging from the largest number alone. A product name describes one quantity; the question you are trying to answer may concern another.
Two similar names, different compositions
We reviewed the manufacturer's current US pages and their linked panel images for Fish Oil 1200 mg, item #1328 and Omega-3 From Fish Oil 1200 mg, item #4296. Both reviewed panels correspond to 100-softgel packs. The first serving is two softgels; the second is one.
| Field | Fish Oil #1328 | Omega-3 From Fish Oil #4296 |
|---|---|---|
| Serving | 2 softgels | 1 softgel |
| Oil / concentrate per serving | 2,400 mg fish oil | 1,200 mg omega-3 concentrate from fish oil |
| Total omega-3 per serving | 720 mg | 720 mg |
| EPA+DHA per serving | 600 mg, combined row | 660 mg, calculated from 360 mg EPA + 300 mg DHA |
| Total omega-3 per softgel | 360 mg | 720 mg |
| EPA+DHA per softgel | 300 mg | 660 mg |
The per-softgel EPA+DHA comparison is 660 ÷ 300 = 2.2. At each product's stated serving, it is 660 ÷ 600 = 1.1. Both calculations are correct. They answer different questions, which is why a comparison should name its denominator before announcing that one product contains “twice as much.”
Keep the nested amounts nested
For #1328, the 600 mg combined EPA+DHA row sits inside the 720 mg total omega-3 amount, which sits inside the 2,400 mg fish-oil amount per serving. Adding those three rows would count some material repeatedly. They are not three independent ingredients to total.
The combined EPA+DHA amount represents 25% of the declared fish-oil mass in that serving. For #4296, 660 ÷ 1,200 gives 55% of the declared concentrate mass. These are label-derived composition fractions. They are not absorption percentages, quality scores or estimates of health benefit.
The NIH Office of Dietary Supplements notes that supplement formulations vary widely and advises checking the types and amounts of omega-3s on the label. “Fish oil,” “total omega-3” and “EPA plus DHA” should therefore stay separate in a record. Other omega-3 fatty acids can contribute to the total.
A combined row does not reveal the split
The reviewed #1328 panel reports EPA and DHA together. It does not separately declare their individual quantities. We leave those two fields unknown in the dataset. We did not borrow a split from a retailer, an older label or another product carrying the same 1200 mg headline.
For #4296, the panel does declare EPA at 360 mg, DHA at 300 mg and other omega-3 at 60 mg. Those add to the stated 720 mg total. For #1328, subtracting the combined 600 mg from the total 720 mg gives a 120 mg remainder by arithmetic; it still does not identify which fatty acids make up that remainder.
This distinction matters for AI-generated comparisons. A blank field can look like a nuisance to be filled. Here it is part of the finding. A system that invents the split may produce a tidier table while making the evidence less reliable.
What this comparison can help you decide
If the practical question is how many units a record represents, normalize to one softgel. If it is what the labeled serving supplies, keep the manufacturer's serving intact. If a clinician has specified an amount of a particular fatty acid, inspect that field with them rather than substituting the total oil mass.
None of those comparisons establishes that the more concentrated product is the right one for you. We did not compare clinical outcomes, contaminant testing, oxidation, tolerability or value for money. We deliberately omitted prices because a price comparison needs an exact pack, seller, date and promotion status. A concentration table cannot quietly stand in for all those separate evaluations.
Nor should the ratios above be used to improvise a new dose. The reviewed labels carry their own directions and cautions, including consulting a physician in specified circumstances such as medication use or blood-clotting issues. A nutrient calculation is not an assessment of those circumstances.
A reusable comparison with visible limits
We manually transcribed the two linked manufacturer panels on November 21, 2026, checked them against the product-page descriptions and calculated the per-softgel values and ratios. No product was purchased or tested. These two deliberately selected US examples show a naming problem; they are not a representative survey of fish oils.
Download the CSV or JSON for exact source images, item identifiers, declared versus calculated fields and missing values. Match your bottle before reusing a row. Our supplement certification reference explains why a seal and a benefit claim require different evidence.
Publisher disclosure: we make Vora, bringing proactive AI together with nutrition, workouts and wearable context. The comparison is complete without signing up. For your own diary, start by checking whether an entry means oil, total omega-3 or EPA+DHA. Vora's features describe the broader product. Corrections: support@askvora.com.